Live data from Hacker News

Viewing profile — xpe

xpe

HN member
Joined
Mon, Aug 27, 2012, 5:47 PM UTC
HN karma
4,501
Public activity
3,359 items

About xpe

Hello HN,

I care a lot about community and discussion quality. With effort, patience, kindness, and curiousity, we can do great things. So let's invest in our culture. Let's strive to get better at learning and listening.

If I was snide or rude to you in the past, I apologize. Life is a journey. Sometimes my desire to state the truth comes too bluntly. I'm aware and error correcting.

I have been accused of writing like an LLM.

If you've made such an accusation at me, I would request that you reconsider. Consider asking "What if I'm wrong?" If you are, there is a person on the other end.

When I hear such an accusation, I have been bothered in the past. But what's the point in that? Lately, I take it as a compliment, since I often rather like how LLMs write, to the extent the sequence of tokens is organized, clear, and the result of an intelligent process.*

More generally, if one doesn't have a reliable way to get to ground truth, one is blind w.r.t. predictive accuracy. Basically, this is a fancy way of saying "recognize your own fallibility" and "calibrate yourself".

If all the above doesn't ~land~ (Claude has ruined this word for me) err.. connect with you, consider this: intellectually humility helps unlock many other valuable things.

Finally, if one can't distinguish human from machine, what follows from that? Think about it. Better yet, write.

Thanks, Xeno Phobia Extractor

* Some examples of what I mean by intelligence:

- intelligence: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43236444

- general intelligence: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43223521

- pressure towards AGI: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41707643

- intelligence as "what machines cannot do" / no physics-based constraints to surpass human intelligence: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44974963

--

Comments and responses licensed under Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) Attribution requirement waived if quoting as a descendant comment on the Hacker News platform only.

^ scrapers, bots, etc., ... this applies to you.

Note: I borrowed the license comment from /user?id=kelseyfrog.

Recent public activity

  1. comment
    Comment #48079863

    Sorry, I was too harsh. Or to be more precise: I should not have directed my criticism only at this particular blog post. This topic is a hot mess. Yes, even the 2019 blog post ann…

  2. comment
    Comment #48037988

    > So on the title, I picked this because it's simply the truth. Since async landed in 2019 or so, not much has changed. Hi. The article calls Rust async an MVP. You should expect s…

  3. comment
    Comment #48036316

    Claim-1: the async versus sync distinction cannot be meaningfully dissolved at the programmer level. Claim-2: async versus sync is a fundamental division in CS Discuss amongst your…

  4. comment
    Comment #47966743

    > Especially for something like a code editor, where plenty of less-shady competitors are available. On what basis are you claiming Zed is shady? I seek evidence, not feels. If you…

  5. comment
    Comment #47966403

    >Several people at work, none use OpenClaw, had their limits jump immediately to 100%. Substantively: assuming this is true, what are the possible explanations? If they don't use O…

  6. comment
    Comment #47966298

    So far, after reading ~20 HN comments, I see one mention of something akin to "I verified this myself". Where are the people saying "Maybe this is true, but please tell me you cons…

  7. comment
    Comment #47957029

    The comment above has started a sh-tstorm. Please, slow down and learn about the details before jumping to conclusions. Most of us here did NOT "go pro" in the law. [1] For those t…

  8. comment
    Comment #47956779

    This language fits common SaaS templates. Let me illustrate by removing chunks and labeling them: Customer hereby grants Zed {{ broad list of rights }} solely: {{ for these purpose…

  9. comment
    Comment #47956450

    1. Yes, Zed is open source, you can build it yourself. 2. Telemetry defaults to on. So turn off telemetry as explained at https://zed.dev/docs/telemetry#configuring-telemetry-setti…

  10. comment
    Comment #47955392

    Which Macs, hardware, OS's? What's your baseline comparison?

  11. comment
    Comment #47950812

    If the idea of hiding extra Markdown elements or making it more WYSIWYG appeals to you, maybe we can put more eyes on some kind of feature request. I've seeing several comments com…

  12. comment
    Comment #47950748

    > Also extensions can't add new UI, so you are stuck fitting to the recipe Zed team provides for you to plug into, and often enough this is not satisfactory. What did you have in m…

  13. comment
    Comment #47950551

    What's your favorite theme, maybe we can point you to something close? If you have any special needs or usability issues (colorblindness is common), that's probably relevant too. I…

  14. comment
    Comment #47950471

    I wish Zed had built-in APIs for extension developers to allow for more customizable text transformations. In particular, I want to write tools that have more control over what a b…

  15. comment
    Comment #47950168

    Here is a top-level comment for people who want to post the things they wish Zed had. Request: please be sincere if you claim "the one thing that keeps me from using Zed is X" ... …

  16. comment
    Comment #47918142

    Thanks. Along those lines, here's a sort of thought experiment. Of said engineers who know a higher standard, say we teleported them into Anthropic, what are some likely scenarios?…

  17. story
  18. comment
    Comment #47911316

    As I understand Anthropic's recent retrospective, calling the models directly via API did not change; the problem was that the harness changed and this was not communicated well to…

  19. comment
    Comment #47911242

    Please link us to it. Linking it provides an anchor for community discussion.

  20. comment
    Comment #47903576

    >> My overall feel is that people underestimate the complexity of the systems at Anthropic and the chaos of the growth. > Do you not think people here work at big companies with bi…

  21. comment
    Comment #47898412

    I personally try to follow Rapoport's Rules, and I since think they are consistent with the HN Guidelines, I like to mention them: [1]. I've thought on it, and I will try to start …

  22. comment
    Comment #47896837

    > You shouldn't have to rely on finding an individual employee's posts on Reddit or X for policy announcements. I agree with this as a principle. Which raises this question: is it …

  23. comment
    Comment #47896654

    Thanks for the example -- you are one of the first people to quote a source, so I appreciate it. This makes constructive discussion much easier. You quoted this: > To manage growin…

  24. comment
    Comment #47896581

    > So you're arguing they're just plain incompetent? Not sure that's going to win the trust of customers either. This is not a charitable interpretation of what I wrote. Please take…

  25. comment
    Comment #47895691

    I also have the same question. That said, for some problems, at least over the last week or so, I did sometimes get better results from lower-effort Opus or even Sonnet. Sometimes …