Live data from Hacker News

Viewing profile — somephilosopher

somephilosopher

HN member
Joined
Wed, Jul 06, 2011, 7:34 AM UTC
HN karma
13
Public activity
6 items

About somephilosopher

No profile information was provided.

Recent public activity

  1. comment
    Comment #2735366

    Weeeeelll, yes and no. But mostly no. There has been a strand of 20 cent philosophy that has regarded justification as that which together with truth and belief yields knowledge - …

  2. comment
    Comment #2734713

    It's not like philosophy is interested in some special notion of 'justified' - philosphy tends to be interested in our ordinary notion of justification. We normally think that the …

  3. comment
    Comment #2734684

    The implicit assumption is: Vx [x thinks > x exists]. You also seem to think that Descartes needs to provide an accont of what it means to exist. Why think that? You speak English.…

  4. comment
    Comment #2733597

    In the example you yourself gave of 'I think therefore I am', the claim following 'therefore' is a conclusion, not a premise. So no, Descartes didn't start with the premise that he…

  5. comment
    Comment #2733581

    Well, meditations wouldn't be a bad place to start. And philosophers differ a lot in their views of teh significance of philosophy. I regard it as self-indulgent, but interesting t…

  6. comment
    Comment #2732905

    I wouldn't downvote anyone, but perhaps because it's a paradigm example of a particular strain of thought you see a lot amongst techie/engineering types with limited experience of …