Live data from Hacker News

Viewing profile — selectron

selectron

HN member
Joined
Sun, Jan 31, 2016, 7:02 PM UTC
HN karma
279
Public activity
87 items

About selectron

No profile information was provided.

Recent public activity

  1. comment
    Comment #12510593

    It is a legitimate question.

  2. comment
    Comment #12510503

    How much better?

  3. comment
    Comment #12510488

    This is a great point about making sensible assumptions. Too often I see evidence that people think that data analysis should be devoid of assumptions, and any assumptions complete…

  4. comment
    Comment #12510459

    Why should we expect there isn't a correlation? They do mention it in their analysis. At the end of the day, just because there might be a systematic bias in your result doesn't me…

  5. comment
    Comment #12510417

    It is always easy to criticize a data-driven analysis by saying its assumptions could be wrong. In the real world, all analysis is based on assumptions, some of which you can alway…

  6. comment
    Comment #12387615

    The main thing I want from job descriptions is a salary range. The fact that companies don't post salaries is a strong counter-point to how companies complain about how hard it is …

  7. comment
    Comment #12245903

    The problem is that the term data analyst has come to mean data reporter. Similarly "business analyst" generally involves tasks that are best solved in Excel. The "science" in data…

  8. comment
    Comment #12200108

    You don't have to be productive all the time. It is important to have some time to relax and have fun. There are far worse things you could be doing than playing too many video gam…

  9. comment
    Comment #12187680

    > Taking papers at face value is really only a problem in science reporting and at (very) sub-par institutions/venues. > WRT the former, science reporters often grossly misundersta…

  10. comment
    Comment #12176879

    The explanation glosses over a few important details. Gradient boosting works by adding some small weight to the instances the model is incorrectly predicting. The amount of extra …

  11. comment
    Comment #12176330

    Feature engineering and model ensembling are usually what separates the top competitors.

  12. comment
    Comment #12171052

    Hand counting of votes seems like a no-brainer, regardless of whether there was a conspiracy this election.

  13. comment
    Comment #12161388

    This statement is too general. You could of said the same thing about chess, there are chess Grandmasters who devote their lives to studying the game yet computers play chess at a …

  14. comment
    Comment #12148626

    I would say that table is really quite valuable. Kaggle problems come from all types of companies, so it doesn't make sense to say that it is "overfitted patterns that he's adopted…

  15. comment
    Comment #12148612

    For image competitions you are right. Neural networks are often in winning teams ensembles, but they require a lot more work than something like xgboost (gradient-boosted decision …

  16. comment
    Comment #12148559

    1) It depends heavily on the model. Something like xgboost (gradient boosted decision tree) will handle irrelevant features fairly well, while other models (like linear models, esp…

  17. comment
    Comment #12134304

    There is no way machine learning will be a necessary skill for software engineering, if that is your motivation I would not spend time learning it. However, if you still want to le…

  18. comment
    Comment #12133506

    My advice is Python, but it depends on what your background is and what you want to do. If this is your first language and you have a stats background, R is a solid choice. If you …

  19. comment
    Comment #12125220

    Interesting. After watching the show Billions, and reading up on how much money hedge fund managers make on fees (seems totally ridiculous), I wonder how common is illegal insider …

  20. comment
    Comment #12101977

    To really understand if companies are biased or not, you also need to know the percent of applicants to these companies who are black. If only 2% of applicants to Google are black,…

  21. comment
    Comment #12098371

    I agree completely. I also think there is way more luck involved than people want to admit - a lot interesting results are unexpected, and there are so few jobs the timing has to w…

  22. comment
    Comment #12097675

    Sorry I wasn't clear - the attitude of going into industry being seen as a failure is common, especially among older professors. This attitude is changing somewhat, but is still de…

  23. comment
    Comment #12097662

    If you just want ROI, you are better off spending your money elsewhere. This is evidenced by the lack of money most companies put into scientific research. Further the gains of sci…

  24. comment
    Comment #12097574

    The problem is that there are plenty of graduate students willing to work for peanuts.

  25. comment
    Comment #12096929

    The goal of research (at least for basic science) isn't to make money, it is to increase knowledge about the universe. This knowledge is a public good, so it makes sense that priva…