Live data from Hacker News

Viewing profile — lo_zamoyski

lo_zamoyski

HN member
Joined
Thu, Sep 01, 2022, 3:44 PM UTC
HN karma
1,985
Public activity
1,874 items

About lo_zamoyski

To mniey boli.

--

"The most important things about beliefs are whether they are true. The most important thing about motives is whether they are good. But motives don’t tell us whether beliefs are true." ― J. Budziszewski

And beliefs don't tell us whether motives are good.

--

Being "nice" is not the same as being "good". Nice people are often some of the worst specimens.

--

When a good and true comment is downvoted, it is actually the downvoter who is demoting himself and removing himself from the kingdom of truth, turning instead toward the darkness.

--

I will, on occasion, steel-man the positions of others in the comments. I do this, because sometimes their positions are not given a fair shake. I take this to be a good act.

--

Let us just say that HN is not exactly the creme-de-la-creme.

--

Sometimes what I say is claimed to be obvious. But this is no defect. Indeed, the fault of the interlocutor is that he fails to draw out the implications of the obvious, hence the reminder of the obvious.

Recent public activity

  1. comment
    Comment #49211661

    > There is no single effect of AI on work quality. Depends on use and effort. Quoting the article... "Nearly half of senior leaders say they would trust a chatbot’s judgment over t…

  2. comment
    Comment #49198806

    I didn't say being phony is a benefit. I was (in my view) charitably giving the author the benefit of the doubt by assuming that his vulgarity is feigned (posturing) and not ingrai…

  3. comment
    Comment #49198726

    Thanks for your response. > I didn’t make that claim in any implied way, I asserted, correctly, that Aristotle is not an Abrahamic thinker. I was trying to make sense of what your …

  4. comment
    Comment #49195846

    What an obnoxious post. Pro-tip: knock off the vulgarity and avoid making ignorant remarks that pander to presently fashionable sentiments. It doesn't "spice up" your text or make …

  5. comment
    Comment #49191358

    > How can we possibly make use of these breakthroughs if we don’t understand them? How could we ever make anything useful with them? Theoretical science isn't about usefulness per …

  6. comment
    Comment #49191301

    It's a category mistake. People try to naturalize Jesus as a "great teacher", but the one thing you cannot do is frame Jesus as another wise man and good teacher! The man claimed t…

  7. comment
  8. comment
    Comment #49191219

    I have no idea what you're trying to say here. Those two sentences seem disconnected. One very common error people make is to believe that ethics - at least epistemically and for t…

  9. comment
    Comment #49182529

    For one, because it's an indicator of health and healthy development, which are in turn related to other desirable features. Analogous things can be said for women. You also can't …

  10. comment
    Comment #49129118

    > now I drink 1 cup of coffee and, if I'm feeling wild, I'll occasionally get an espresso. FYI, unless we're talking double espresso, a typical shot of espresso contains less caffe…

  11. comment
    Comment #49028529

    You may dislike buying used books like that, but the purpose of the previous owner wasn't to satisfy your future desire for a pristine copy. The purpose was his own knowledge. If t…

  12. comment
    Comment #49010799

    I appreciate that this is a topic of discussion, whatever defects the author's post contains, both explicit and tacit. Some commentary: 1. Ethics is the practical science (in the b…

  13. comment
    Comment #49005103

    The trouble is that the definition of "castle" varies considerably between countries. For instance, the German classification divides them into "Schloss" and "Burg", but these can …

  14. comment
    Comment #48981493

    Perfection is always relative to a purpose or telos . So in the case of artifacts - which are the products of engineering, arts, and techne in general - the purpose isn't inherent …

  15. comment
    Comment #48977859

    > why did you hire these morons? The democratic process is the selection of incompetent people by unqualified people.

  16. comment
    Comment #48957559

    A good question to pose to Sam.

  17. comment
    Comment #48957553

    Interesting Rorschach test.

  18. comment
    Comment #48906519

    The very consumerism that has made it materially wealthy has fucked up its citizens' priorities. Indeed, because the wealth differential over the last 30 years is as steep as it is…

  19. comment
    Comment #48906388

    Not really. You can be honest about something working and others can disagree with your assessment.

  20. comment
    Comment #48865457

    I'd have to look deeper into his views, but I've already come across what seem like similar claims that try to attribute computation to the laws of physics or to matter in general …

  21. comment
    Comment #48861561

    Whatever one might say about method, epistemically speaking, the aesthetic is prior to the mathematical. The mathematical is found in the analysis of the beautiful.

  22. comment
    Comment #48861473

    > I love how artistic taste can be partially derived from math [...] the math itself isn't sufficient to develop artistic taste Strictly speaking, it isn't "math" as math is the sc…

  23. comment
    Comment #48851447

    And if we're talking Ukraine, we have to talk Poland as it has been facilitating 90% of all Western military equipment, humanitarian aid, and crucial trade deliveries into the coun…

  24. comment
    Comment #48761376

    The "man-o-sphere" is pornographic. Look at the porn-brained Tate brothers for an example. That is their whole ethos and their souls are rotted out by it. Both are based in dehuman…

  25. comment
    Comment #48751273

    > Science can't disprove religion. That depends on which religion, doesn't it. The categorical claim doesn't make any sense, because the general notion of "religion" doesn't entail…