Live data from Hacker News

Viewing profile — jmmcd

jmmcd

HN member
Joined
Wed, Sep 30, 2009, 9:47 PM UTC
HN karma
1,374
Public activity
565 items

About jmmcd

I'm a lecturer and researcher in computer science and AI in Ireland. I'm into music, computer music, programs, and programs that write programs.

Recent public activity

  1. comment
    Comment #48719699

    A lot of us went through a similar system and still retained both honour and desire to actually learn.

  2. comment
    Comment #48702525

    It's interesting that Claude also over-uses en -dashes. It's very willing to create compound-noun-phrases, especially in that compressed-summary-paragraph it often writes. The 0-da…

  3. comment
    Comment #48501966

    People are missing that Willison is among the very best people we have in the role of (for lack of a good name): early access to frontier models, evaluate them in real scenarios, n…

  4. comment
    Comment #48214959

    > LLMs do just interpolate their training data "interpolate" has a technical meaning - in this meaning, LLMs almost never interpolate. It also has a very vague everyday meaning - i…

  5. comment
    Comment #47873402

    But euros spent on tokens is a tiny fraction of the overall costs of the project.

  6. comment
    Comment #47840650

    > Since these companies can’t improve their AI models without fresh data created by human beings Totally wrong. Self-play dates back to Arthur Samuel in the 1950s and RL with verif…

  7. comment
    Comment #47706359

    > Anglo Please, write US-American. These people are not coming from any other place.

  8. comment
    Comment #46994699

    I understand your point, but in response to GP (they should spend this money on houses for other poor people instead), the reduced reliance on other social welfare is totally legit…

  9. comment
    Comment #46988074

    You didn't read the article. The scheme gave positive return on investment.

  10. comment
    Comment #46726144

    Google Scholar provides imperfect citations - very often wrong article type (eg article versus conference paper), but up to and including missing authors, in my experience.

  11. comment
    Comment #46599486

    Jokes are one of the good parts of human existence, so - while I see your side of the story - there is another side.

  12. comment
  13. comment
    Comment #46526484

    The best example of all is Prolog. It is always held up as the paradigmatic representative of logic programming, a rare language paradigm. But it doesn't need to be a language. It …

  14. comment
    Comment #45978693

    But he actually uses frontier LLMs in his own work. Probably that's stronger evidence.

  15. comment
    Comment #45977376

    Yes. But "the gold standard" just means "the most natural, easy and dumb way".

  16. comment
    Comment #45977363

    This is on the semi-private set * https://x.com/arcprize/status/1990820655411909018 * https://arcprize.org/guide

  17. comment
    Comment #45968046

    "Pelican on bicycle" is one special case, but the problem (and the interesting point) is that with LLMs, they are always generalising. If a lab focussed specially on pelicans on bi…

  18. comment
    Comment #45964677

    About ARC 2: I would want to hear more detail about prompts, frameworks, thinking time, etc., but they don't matter too much. The main caveat would be that this is probably on the …

  19. comment
    Comment #45049796

    On HN it's very common to see a blog post along the lines of "I found this old piece of equipment with no brand name, I used some network traffic inspection to figure out what it d…

  20. comment
    Comment #44680950

    (a) no it's not (b) your comment is miles off-topic, as he is not addressing doom in any sense

  21. comment
    Comment #44474601

    But they're submissions to ICML.

  22. comment
    Comment #44136849

    It could certainly replace the author of this article.

  23. comment
    Comment #44106249

    Modern LLMs can one-shot code in a totally new language, if you provide the language manual. And you have to provide the language manual, because otherwise how can the students lea…

  24. comment
    Comment #44106213

    > The fact that AI can do your homework should tell you how much your homework is worth. A lot of people who say this kind of thing have, frankly, a very shallow view of what homew…

  25. comment
    Comment #43843846

    Absolutely devastating for the credibility of FAIR.