Live data from Hacker News

Viewing profile — idohft

idohft

HN member
Joined
Mon, Apr 07, 2014, 3:30 PM UTC
HN karma
38
Public activity
22 items

About idohft

I have a normal account too, but I use this to comment on finance-adjacent topics. I'm keeping this separate because financey discussions can get heated (rife with accusations and namecalling), and I don't want people harassing me in real life.

I used to be in HFT, traded quite a few asset classes, know some about market structure, and have thought a lot about price movement.

Recent public activity

  1. comment
    Comment #44841899

    > Its a finance firm - i.e scam firm. "We have a fancy trading algorithm that statistically is never going to outperform just buying VOO and holding it, but the thing is if you get…

  2. comment
    Comment #40918250

    What exactly do you mean when you say this: > IIRC they can legally front-run your orders. I doubt this is true, but there are definitions attached to front-running.

  3. comment
    Comment #40910149

    How far have you tried to tell, and do you buy/sell stocks? There's someone on the other side of your trade when you want to trade something. You're more likely than not choosing t…

  4. comment
    Comment #33555038

    This comment, and its posters' subsequent comments, are so filled with anger, much misguided, that it's hard to really respond. Jane Street has some good people. Harvard has some g…

  5. comment
    Comment #31239515

    Hard to speak for HFT in general. Like in software, different firms have different levels of hygiene. About half of your bullet points were true of my previous employer, at my time…

  6. comment
    Comment #30196987

    Jump is very profitable.

  7. comment
    Comment #24366727

    I can see how you can come to this conclusion from this sentence, but it's a vague sentence with slightly-wrong premises, which leads you to this conclusion. If you're a programmer…

  8. comment
    Comment #23217340

    I'm going to have to jump in here and say, no, HFT can and does not front-run your trade. There are reasons why your execution on RH is not as good as professionals, but it's not b…

  9. comment
    Comment #23191255

    Agreed with the rest, you should just look at job descriptions. Different firms use different technologies, but a devops person will probably be building tooling for monitoring liv…

  10. comment
    Comment #23026183

    I have to disagree, I know that HFT != electronic trading. HFT is also not equivalent to arbing over latency.

  11. comment
    Comment #23025563

    You were replied to, but I'm going to ask some questions of this moralizing. > Many HFT jump out when things get volatile, when liquidity is actually required. This feels almost li…

  12. comment
    Comment #23023470

    ++ this. If they haven't tested this in actual trades and measured results, it's probably worthless. Even backtested strategies at actual firms observe decays (or don't work) when …

  13. comment
    Comment #14333282

    (1) -- ok, sure (2). That is not what I said. To sell at P+dP, you need to buy up all the shares at P+dP as well. That's because of price-time priority, which almost all the major …

  14. comment
    Comment #14333169

    This doesn't sound right. Some points: - A trader looking to buy futures is almost certainly not going to send their order to several exchanges. The main exchanges list distinct co…

  15. comment
    Comment #12336742

    I'm in HFT (as per my handle). Exchanges like NYSE, NASDAQ, etc. sell stock data to firms but not before they get processed . The only way you get front run is if the broker that y…

  16. comment
    Comment #7857353

    I think it's pretty clear that HFT has a big role in this. If you look at the order books of US equities, most of the most aggressive orders on the book are ones that look like the…

  17. comment
    Comment #7854734

    In response to situation (2), I want to first tighten the language - as it stands, I'm not sure if it's even possible. By computers, I think you mean exchanges (for example, Nasdaq…

  18. comment
    Comment #7854618

    The industry doesn't really make that much money. Estimates for this past year were in the $1-2 billion range. That's not big for the finance sector, or any industry. That being sa…

  19. comment
    Comment #7854602

    Vanguard, the world's biggest mutual fund, notes that their costs have gone down since HFT has come into play. http://www.cnbc.com/id/101615521

  20. comment
    Comment #7853864

    I can't reply to that thread (maybe it's because it was too long ago), but you draw a difference between someone moving a large block (as described in yummyfajitas' post), and some…

  21. comment
    Comment #7853442

    Where does this assertion come from? If you take a look at the market book, then you might see that yes, most market-makers (liquidity) in the equity markets are high-frequency ord…

  22. comment
    Comment #7577113

    Maybe he's not a sinister person, but he tells narratives in which his side is unambiguously good. What happened in this book was lazy research and poor journalism. There have been…