Live data from Hacker News

Viewing profile — fchollet

fchollet

HN member
Joined
Thu, Nov 14, 2024, 7:16 AM UTC
HN karma
376
Public activity
31 items

About fchollet

No profile information was provided.

Recent public activity

  1. comment
    Comment #47539097

    It is 100% ARC-AGI-3 specific though, just read through the prompts https://github.com/symbolica-ai/ARC-AGI-3-Agents/blob/symbol...

  2. comment
    Comment #47523468

    There are no tricks. Our approach to reducing the impact of targeting (without fully eliminating it) is described in the paper.

  3. comment
    Comment #47523458

    I'm all for testing humans and AI on a fair basis; how about we restrict testing to robots physically coming to our testing center to solve the environments via keyboard / mouse / …

  4. comment
    Comment #47522882

    Francois here. The scoring metric design choices are detailed in the technical report: https://arcprize.org/media/ARC_AGI_3_Technical_Report.pdf - the metric is meant to discount b…

  5. comment
    Comment #45838471

    One interesting observation is that French-derived words in English tend to be fancier -- formal, sophisticated, higher-class -- while Germanic ones tend to be more casual, everyda…

  6. comment
    Comment #43467150

    The first time a top lab spent millions trying to beat ARC was actually in 2021, and the effort failed. By the time OpenAI attempted ARC in 2024, a colossal amount of resources had…

  7. comment
    Comment #43467083

    You can easily convert these tasks to token strings. The reason why ARC does not use language as part of its format is that it seeks to minimize the amount of prior knowledge neede…

  8. comment
    Comment #43466922

    The reason these tasks require fluid intelligence is because they were designed this way -- with task uniqueness/novelty as the primary goal. ARC 1 was released long before in-cont…

  9. comment
    Comment #43466902

    There have been some human studies on ARC 1 previously, I expect there will be more in the future. See this paper from 2021, which was one of the earliest works in this direction: …

  10. comment
    Comment #43466887

    It's useful to know what current AI systems can achieve with unlimited test-time compute resources. Ultimately though, the "spirit of the challenge" is efficiency, which is why we'…

  11. comment
    Comment #43465929

    ARC 3 is still spatially 2D, but it adds a time dimension, and it's interactive.

  12. comment
    Comment #42833266

    > Who would be buying bitcoin right now? Well, maybe the US government? What if the US starts dedicating 10-15% of yearly federal receipts to serve as exit liquidity for Bitcoin ho…

  13. comment
    Comment #42344425

    What all top models do is recombine at test time the knowledge they already have. So they all possess Core Knowledge priors. Techniques to acquire them vary: * Use a pretrained LLM…

  14. comment
    Comment #42344172

    It is correct that the first model that will beat ARC-AGI will only be able to handle ARC-AGI tasks. However, the idea is that the architecture of that model should be able to be r…

  15. comment
    Comment #42145266

    I will never enter ARC Prize myself, since I'm organizing it. But the reason I made ARC in the first place was to work on it myself! I intend to solve it (outside of the context of…

  16. comment
    Comment #42145253

    ARC was never supposed to grade LLMs! I designed the ARC format back when LLMs weren't a thing at all. It's a test of AI systems' ability to generalize to novel tasks.

  17. comment
    Comment #42145249

    I believe the MindsAI solution does feature novel ideas that do indeed lead to better generalization (test-time fine-tuning). So it's definitely the kind of research that ARC was s…

  18. comment
    Comment #42135855

    My go-to DL stack is Keras 3 + JAX. W&B is a great tool as well. I think JAX is generally under-appreciated compared to how powerful it is.

  19. comment
    Comment #42134984

    Keras is now standalone and multi-backend again. Keras weights files from older versions are still loadable and Keras code from older versions are still runnable (on any backend as…

  20. comment
    Comment #42134645

    This roughly aligns with my timeline. ARC will be solved within a couple of years. There is a distinction between solving ARC, creating AGI, and creating an AI that would represent…

  21. comment
    Comment #42134465

    Yes to both.

  22. comment
    Comment #42134352

    Actually, `keras.distribution` is straightforward to implement in TF DTensor and with the experimental PyTorch SPMD API. We haven't done it yet first because these APIs are experim…

  23. comment
    Comment #42134344

    Enjoy the book!

  24. comment
    Comment #42134343

    That's what I plan on doing -- so I would say yes :)

  25. comment
    Comment #42134167

    Thank you!