Live data from Hacker News

Viewing profile — ctbergstrom

ctbergstrom

HN member
Joined
Sun, Feb 09, 2025, 8:20 AM UTC
HN karma
357
Public activity
19 items

About ctbergstrom

Biology prof at U. Washington.

I study how information flows in biology, science, and society.

Book: Calling Bullshit, tinyurl.com/fdcuvd7b

Online LLM course: thebullshitmachines.com

Corvids: tinyurl.com/mr2n5ymk

he/him

Recent public activity

  1. comment
    Comment #43022419

    I very much like this analogy. Thank you for making this clearer in my mind.

  2. comment
    Comment #42997536

    We've discussed Cohen's work in our book _Calling Bullshit_, but the type of bullshit the Cohen focuses on — unclarifiable unclarity, particularly in academic writing — is not what…

  3. comment
    Comment #42995312

    That's entirely true. We've tried hard to stick with general principles that we don't think will readily be overturned. But doubtless we've been too assertive for some people's tas…

  4. comment
    Comment #42995076

    Yep, I probably did. I really appreciate all of the feedback people are providing!

  5. comment
    Comment #42994948

    Yes! First, thank you for the link about CoT misrepresentation. I've written a fair bit about this on Bluesky etc but I don't think much if any of that made it into the course yet.…

  6. comment
    Comment #42994915

    This is an excellent point about scientific writing. We'll add something to that effect. We have not taught this course from the web-based materials yet, but it distills much of th…

  7. comment
    Comment #42994494

    This is something we've given serious consideration, having taught a course called "Calling Bullshit" ( http://callingbullshit.org ) for almost a decade and having authored a book …

  8. comment
    Comment #42994455

    You're right of course. In the original drafts I had a long section on this, including some of the history of the GUI, the development of the mouse, etc. It was way too much for th…

  9. comment
    Comment #42994433

    After talking to an awful lot of 18-20 year olds (our target audience) we decided we wanted to go with a "scrollytellying" style. I'm not a designer and I've done worked in that st…

  10. comment
    Comment #42994368

    I'm surprised at the firefox problems; I did almost all the development in firefox. I know it's not your job to fix any of this, but if you are so inclined I'd be grateful for an e…

  11. comment
    Comment #42994360

    Many comments about this, so I'll address them here. We talked extensively with the 18-20 year olds who make up our target demographic and this "scrollytelling" style is their stro…

  12. comment
    Comment #42994290

    Yes—I should have stressed that. More than anything, we've talked at great lengths about LLMs with over a thousand undergraduate students who we have taught in our courses since Ch…

  13. comment
    Comment #42994261

    We asked our target audience, 19-year-olds. They had a strong preference for this style. I know....

  14. comment
    Comment #42994259

    Thank you, and as a non-designer, I've been quite impressed with Shorthand in the short time I've been using it.

  15. comment
    Comment #42994246

    Absolutely. Great point. I just finished updating accordingly. My design options are a bit limited so I went with a simple link to the next lesson.

  16. comment
    Comment #42994240

    Thank you very much — fixed!

  17. comment
  18. comment
  19. story
    Modern-Day Oracles or Bullshit Machines? How to thrive in a ChatGPT world

    Jevin West and I are professors of data science and biology, respectively, at the University of Washington. After talking to literally hundreds of educators, employers, researchers…