Live data from Hacker News

Viewing profile — bolu

bolu

HN member
Joined
Tue, Feb 09, 2010, 4:04 AM UTC
HN karma
76
Public activity
32 items

About bolu

Co-Founder of FutureAdvisor, YC 2010. http://www.futureadvisor.com

Recent public activity

  1. story
  2. story
  3. job
    Help middle-class families secure their financial future (FutureAdvisor S10)

    Engineers probably have more leverage now than at any other time in history. We can now make great tools that empower large numbers of people in a matter of days. Join our team of …

  4. job
  5. job
    FutureAdvisor (YC S10): Help middle-class families secure their financial future

    Engineers probably have more leverage now than at any other time in history. We can now make great tools that empower large numbers of people in a matter of days. Join our team of …

  6. job
    FutureAdvisor (YC S10): Help middle-class families secure their financial future

    Engineers probably have more leverage now than at any other time in history. We can now make great tools that empower large numbers of people in a matter of days. Join our team of …

  7. comment
    Comment #6733189

    This reminds me of YC's "Apply without an idea" experiment. Both experiments seem to arise from a innovator's insight that a whole class of otherwise highly qualified candidates se…

  8. story
  9. story
  10. job
    Head up inbound marketing at FutureAdvisor (YC S10)

    FutureAdvisor is an eight-person, Sequoia-backed startup remaking saving & investing for the average American family. Today customers already entrust us to advise them on $4 Billio…

  11. job
    Full-stack engineer at FutureAdvisor: reduce Wall Street's take of our savings

    FutureAdvisor is an eight-person, Sequoia-backed startup remaking saving & investing for the average American family. Today customers already entrust us to advise them on $4 Billio…

  12. comment
    Comment #3545230

    Active investors of all kinds definitely try, but again as a whole they've failed. I'll try to dig up the data and put it into an article sometime, but the fallacy that you should …

  13. comment
    Comment #3545224

    Thats true, but we must remember that for folks who _did_ try to time the market many will have actually had negative returns because of failing timing attempts. For example, there…

  14. comment
    Comment #3545131

    Your point about the single month as the timing period is definitely valid - in hindsight the article would have benefitted from having that be maybe 6 months or 12 months instead.…

  15. comment
    Comment #3545087

    You've pointed out the exact nature of the problem. They made a killing that day, and they probably will continue to make a killing as long as naive investors believe they can beat…

  16. comment
    Comment #3544402

    They're both part of the same story: that individual investors are bad at this, and professional managers aren't any good at it either. Fair point though, that was definitely a con…

  17. comment
    Comment #3544356

    Good question. The inflow/outflow data is from the ICI (Investment Company Institute - a consortium of fund companies) and is dollars in/out which is independent of asset performan…

  18. comment
    Comment #3544328

    Indeed - yet individual investors try anyway, and the futility of this is all we're trying to point out.

  19. comment
    Comment #3544313

    You're right that the article should have been more clear - it's looking at retail investors specifically (in your example; Person2), which is the audience that FutureAdvisor focus…

  20. comment
    Comment #3544255

    Because we used the inflows & outflows of a couple large retail mutual funds as proxy for investor demand, you're right that the story actually is "retail investors are bad at timi…

  21. comment
    Comment #3544239

    Good data for the performance of hedge funds as an asset class that account for survivorship bias is somewhat hard to find. Off hand, Swensen in "Unconventional Success" recounts t…

  22. comment
    Comment #3445255

    Well, just like the average retail investor buys last year's hot mutual fund in the hopes that (usually lucky) outperformance persists, institutional investors also got sold the "l…

  23. comment
    Comment #3398409

    The Emperor of All Maladies - spectacular journey into the history of the disease. Filled with great human stories of discovery, and also taught me a ton about the currently unders…

  24. story
  25. comment
    Comment #2082106

    You're absolutely right, and I agree with your advice. Also contributing to your 401(k) - assuming your options aren't terrible - is in the same realm of advice. We should have bee…