Viewing profile — anishrverma

We just posted a preprint describing one of the core technical ideas behind Liberata, in replacing discrete authorship positions with continuous contribution shares, then combining…

Agreed. Accountability matters, but changing the game usually scales better than hoping for better individual behaviour under the same pressures. Academia needs systems that reward…

[dead]

This is what makes the problem feel so systemic, in that weak consequences after the fact, and weak incentives for transparency before the fact. If the system mostly rewards output…

I think this is the right tension, in that bad incentives matter, but that does not remove personal responsibility. We probably need both stronger accountability for clear miscondu…

This (also) feels like a core failure mode, in that papers are optimized for skim-level persuasion because the system is too overloaded for deep evaluation at scale. Then a lot of …

This feels like a core failure mode: papers are optimized for skim-level persuasion because the system is too overloaded for deep evaluation at scale. Then a lot of the actual scru…

Strongly agree. When code, data, and workflow details stay hidden, the system rewards claims more than verification. That is where shortcuts, irreproducibility, and worse can thriv…

I think this is exactly the hard part: individual virtue alone does not solve a system where supervisors, trainees, and funders are all pulled by the same incentives. "Do slower, b…

[dead]

I don’t read the NeurIPS statement as malicious per se, but I do think it’s incomplete They’re right that a citation error doesn’t automatically invalidate the technical content of…

Yeah, spot on. If all we do is add more plausible sounding text on top of already fragile review and incentive structures, that really could make things worse rather than better Yo…

Agreed. What I find more interesting is how easy these errors are to introduce and how unlikely they are to be caught. As you point out, a DOI checker would immediately flag this. …

The prevalence of hallucinations in the system is another signs for change in the system. The citations should be treated less like narrative context and more like verifiable objec…