Live data from Hacker News

Viewing profile — HTryan

HTryan

HN member
Joined
Tue, Jun 12, 2012, 8:48 PM UTC
HN karma
3
Public activity
5 items

About HTryan

No profile information was provided.

Recent public activity

  1. comment
    Comment #4102929

    I think one of the primary issues with popular music is that it's often ambiguous whether it's in a major or minor mode, even when the song starts on a minor chord. Classically, on…

  2. comment
    Comment #4102894

    Good points. Many rules in popular music come directly from classical music (after all, it's been around for a while). However, as you can see in the Hooktheory database, there are…

  3. comment
    Comment #4102833

    Hey Jimmy, Hooktheory stores all of its chord progressions in relative notation so we have tools to answer questions like the one you've posted here. Although the Hooktheory databa…

  4. comment
    Comment #4102798

    Right, all of the songs were normalized to C, which exactly the point. At Hooktheory.com you can examine all of the songs in relative notation (i.e. I IV V in place of C F G) which…

  5. comment
    Comment #4102779

    Exactly. D Major chord is a V/V in C Major, which has only a couple of common uses in popular music according to the Hooktheory database. V/V -> V7 -> I is one common one. Another …